European Institute for Studies on
the Middle East and North Africa

From Kirkuk to Deir ez-Zor: Threatened Kurdish Autonomies

Destitute Syrians who've flocked to rebel-held eastern Syria have taken to the oil fields of Deir Ez-Zor to earn what they can, refining oil from what were once government lands into diesel fuel.

Author

“From Kirkuk to Deir ez-Zor: Threatened Kurdish Autonomies”

On Saturday, September 2, 2023, violent riots broke out in Kirkuk, Iraq, resulting in the deaths of four individuals, all of Kurdish ethnicity. The return of a city building to the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) served as the pretext for these ethnically charged demonstrations, as Arabs and Turkmen clashed with Kurds. This episode reflects the communal tensions present in Iraq, which are, of course, exploited by the Iraqi government and especially its Iranian backers. Can we draw parallels between this conflict and the uprising in Deir ez-Zor, Syria, where Arab tribes from the Euphrates Valley took up arms to drive out the Syrian Democratic Forces, predominantly led by the Kurds?

Balanche, F. (2023). The Iranian Axis Threatens Kurdish Autonomies [cartographic document].
1cm = 200km.

Kirkuk is a multi-ethnic city that is part of the disputed territories between the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) and Iraq. The Kurdish administration and fighters of the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) and the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) were expelled by pro-Iranian Shiite militias (Hashd al-Shaabi) in October 2017, who now control the city, relying in particular on the Shiite Turkmen minority and some Sunni Arab clans. Empowered by their new authority, they attempt to seize Kurdish lands and properties, forcing the Kurds to leave the region. In Deir ez-Zor, the population is exclusively Sunni Arab, but divided into various rival tribes. Some of them support the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria (AANES) and are heavily involved with the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), while others remain hostile and maintain strong sympathies for ISIS.

It appears that we are in two different contexts, but they are actually very similar, as they both stem from an anti-Kurdish sentiment in both Iraq and Syria. In Deir ez-Zor, Arab tribes resent being part of an entity led by Kurds. They blame them for all the problems in the region, accuse them of taking “their oil,” and keeping them in destitution, as I personally observed during a recent trip to the area. In Iraq, I gathered similar testimonies against the Kurds, who are accused, among other things, of monopolizing the Iraqi budget, stealing hydrocarbons, and obstructing the reconstruction of Mosul. Resorting to Israel to divert public anger from the authorities seems to no longer be effective, as the Kurds have become the new scapegoats. The KRG’s impressive economic success, the security it maintains, and the quality of public services further fuel this animosity.

The anti-Kurdish sentiment is being exploited by Arab leaders in Damascus and Baghdad who seek to eradicate both Kurdish entities. It’s important to remember that the KRG and the AANES emerged following the collapse of these central states during the American invasion in Iraq and the Syrian civil war. The weakening of Western influence in the Middle East, the strengthening of both the Syrian and Iraqi regimes, both supported by Iran, raises questions about the very existence of the KRG and the AANES Additionally, we must consider Turkey’s neo-Ottoman strategy, which currently doesn’t pose a threat to the KRG but clearly targets the AANES. It is within this geopolitical context that we must analyze the recent events in Kirkuk and Deir ez-Zor.

The strategic importance of both regions, due to the presence of oil, is also worth emphasizing. Kirkuk accounts for 15% of Iraqi production, and Deir ez-Zor holds 70% of Syrian oil reserves. The resources in Kirkuk allowed the KRG to become less reliant on the budget allocated by Baghdad under the 2005 constitution. This is why pro-Iranian Shiite militias swiftly took control of the region after the Kurdistan independence referendum in 2017. The hydrocarbons in Deir ez-Zor are a key bargaining chip for the AANES in negotiations with Damascus and, more importantly, for securing its energy supply. Deprived of this resource, the de facto autonomy of Northeastern Syria would be significantly undermined.

Damascus and Tehran have a clear interest in supporting the uprising of Arab tribes to reintegrate this territory and its oil into a devastated Syria. However, they may not necessarily have the means for this ambition, and more importantly, the rebellious tribes may not want to return under Bashar al-Assad’s control. They rather naively imagine being able to create a small Arab kingdom and thus benefit from the oil wealth, but for this, they would need external protection. However, the United States is not inclined to invest in such a venture, and Turkey is too far away to take a keen interest in Deir ez-Zor. The scenario of Kirkuk in 2017 could therefore be repeated in Deir ez-Zor: an invasion led by Iraqi Shiite militias. Iran would strengthen its Syrian ally in this way and push American troops to leave, thereby expanding its strategic corridor between Tehran and Beirut. However, to complete the construction of this famous “Shiite crescent”[2] that began with the fall of Saddam Hussein in 2003, it must rid itself of the pro-Western autonomous Kurdish territories.

In Iraq, the KRG is under pressure from the pro-Iranian government in Baghdad, which is withholding its share of the budget and blocking its oil exports via Turkey, depriving it of financial resources. It is hard not to see in the Kirkuk affair the beginning of a pro-Iranian intervention against the KRG if the latter does not yield to Iranian demands to disarm the Iranian Kurdish opposition groups present on its territory and to allow the Iraqi army to control its border. Tehran’s ultimatum expires on September 19th. In Syria, Iran has fewer levers, but it relies on the Turkish threat to bring the AANES back under Damascus’ control. While the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) remain capable of stopping an attack by pro-Turkish Arab militias equipped with light weapons, they would not be able to repel a coordinated offensive with Turkish air and artillery support, as in October 2019.

The Persian and Ottoman empires are threatening Kurdish autonomies with military interventions that would be fatal for them, but are currently challenging to implement due to opposition from the United States. Waiting for a new American president to decide to withdraw troops from the region. Meanwhile, both empires are working to destabilize them, one in Syria and the other in Iraq, using various means: economic blockade, water retention, regular bombings, support for rebel groups, bellicose declarations, and more. These tactics cultivate an atmosphere of insecurity that is detrimental to the economy. The objective is to drive away the active forces, sow political divisions, and incite revolts, making it easier to deliver the decisive blow later on.

Notes

[1] Fabrice Balanche, From the Iranian Corridor to the Shia Crescent, Hoover Institution Press, 2018.

To cite this article: “From Kirkuk to Deir ez-Zor: Threatened Kurdish Autonomies” by Fabrice Balanche, EISMENA, 08/09/2023, [https://eismena.com/analysis/from-kirkuk-to-deir-ez-zor-threatened-kurdish-autonomies/].

The information and opinion contained in the articles on the EISMENA website are solely those of the author(s) and do not engage the responsibility of the institute.

Share this article

The War Trump Dreams To Win

On 28 February 2026, the United States and Israel launched what Trump described as ‘major combat operations’ against Iran, and the initial strikes killed Ayatollah Ali Khamenei himself, along with several high-ranking commanders. This campaign was explicitly aimed at overthrowing the Islamic Republic. Seven months later, the war is described as a ‘stalemate’: the US Navy has devastated the Iranian fleet and destroyed much of its radar coverage, but Iran continues to carry out raids on the waterway through which a fifth of the world’s oil passes, and both sides are vying for control of it. The question on the minds of millions of people across the Middle East and as far afield as Europe is whether Donald Trump understands that no American weapon can wipe out or destroy Iran.

Read More »

Rewarded Either Way: Morocco, the EU and the Paradox of Border Externalisation after Ceuta

The July 2026 Ceuta crisis, during which an estimated 72,000 people crossed the border from Morocco, exposed a paradox in the EU’s externalisation of migration management. Relying on transit states to limit crossings also gives those states bargaining power. This article examines EU–Morocco cooperation and competing explanations for the crisis, from structural pressures and failures of anticipation to the possible instrumentalisation of migration flows. Both interpretations point to the same vulnerability: the EU’s dependence on Moroccan cooperation. The article situates Ceuta within a broader policy model by examining the European response and comparing Morocco with Tunisia. It concludes that externalisation does not guarantee containment and that the pursuit of greater control may deepen the EU’s reliance on transit states.

Read More »

Jurf al-Sakhar: Ali al-Zaidi faces the military and economic power of Kata’ib Hezbollah

In an interview with Kurdistan 24, on November 16, 2026, Dr. Adel Bakawan, Director of the European Institute for Studies on the Middle East and North Africa (EISMENA), described Jurf al-Sakhar as one of the first tests of credibility facing Iraqi Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi’s gouvernement. Beyond the question of the return of approximately 129,000 people displaced since 2014, the research portrays a territory under the effective control of Kata’ib Hezbollah, where military infrastructure, clandestine prisons and parallel economic activities would constitute major obstacles to the exercise of state authority. His analysis highlights the gap between the Prime Minister’s constitutional powers and the balance of power underpinning Iraq’s political system.

Read More »

Related Articles

The War Trump Dreams To Win

Hichem Karoui

Rewarded Either Way: Morocco, the EU and the Paradox of Border Externalisation after Ceuta

Amelia Aguirrezabal Ortega

Jurf al-Sakhar: Ali al-Zaidi faces the military and economic power of Kata’ib Hezbollah

Adel Bakawan

From the Algiers Doctrine to the Madama Forward Operating Position: Anatomy of a Strategic Realignment in the Sahel

Imen Chaanbi

In Lebanon, the End of a Sense of Superiority? The Shiite Community Facing Hezbollah’s Decline

Lyna Ouandjeli

Could Coalition Withdrawal Increase or Reduce Threats to Iraqi Kurdistan?

Wladimir van Wilgenburg